Wednesday, February 14, 2018

Hawkeyes Tonight! Domers Get NCAA'd, Sparty & More


The Hawkeyes
Whatever you’re doing tonight for Valentine’s Day, get it done quick as Michigan plays at 6:30.  And of course, the Olympics are on, too….
Games – Dates – Time – Result - Record
Illinois(H)                  January 6th               Noon                          WON  79-69              14-3
Purdue (H)                January 9th               9:00 PM                     Lost    70-69              14-4
Sparty (A)                   January 13th              Noon                          WON  82-72              15-4
Maryland (H)            January 15th            6:30 PM                     WON 68-67               16-4
Nebraska (A)             January 18th              8:00 PM                     LOST 72-52              16-5
Rutgers (H)              January 21st             Noon                          WON  62-47              17-5
Purdue (A)                 January 25th              7:00 PM                     LOST  92-88             17-6
Northwestern (H)    January 29th            7:00 PM                     WON  58-47              18-6
Minnesota (H)          February 3rd             2:30 PM                     WON  76-73 (OT)    19-6
Northwestern (A)      February 6th              6:00PM                      LOST  61-52             19-7
Wiscy (A)                   February 11th            Noon                          WON  83-72              20-7
Iowa   (H)                   February 14th           6:30 PM
Suckeyes (H)           February 18th           1:00 PM
PSU (A)                      February 21st            7:00 PM
Maryland (A)             February 24th            Noon
Think Sparty is PISSED with the #3 Seed?
I do.  And they took it out on the Lowly Gophers last night in an 87-57 rout.  Yep, don’t piss off Sparty with a crappy seed.  They can lose in the round of 32 or the Sweet 16 no matter where you seed them, but they prefer to be seeded higher when they lose!!!
Lunardi, KenPom, BPI, RPI And Too Much Info      
One of my daily lunch time rituals during the month of February is to check out the following links or websites to see where things are at and how they’re moving. 
Lunardi’s Bracketology
I like Lunardi until I don’t.  Lunardi jumped Michigan 2 SEED LINES (Michigan now a #6-Seed) in the latest update.  Apparently, that has to do with Sparty being a 3-Seed and Michigan winning at Sparty.  And 2 good losses to the Boilers.  Lunardi shuffled a bunch of teams around from his last update based on what the committee posted on the Top 16 teams.  Oklahoma as a 4-Seed definitely messed some stuff up for a lot of Bracketologists.  I have a feeling the committee may downgrade the Laters in the next reveal.  Just a hunch. IF Michigan can win out and get to 24 wins, that might be enough to move them up a seed line, assuming some other folks nosedive at the end of the season. (and a split with the Suckeyes would definitely help) The 5-Seed Line would be nice
ESPN’s Own BPI (Put together with Jay Bilas’ assistance) is more or less a mirror of KenPom, but let’s ESPN manage and use this and they don’t have to pay or say “KenPom” and he can’t sue them.  Michigan is ranked #25 in the ESPN BPI.
KenPom is a great site as it has what is arguably the Best Statistical ranking system and Ken constantly tweeks the system if the data dictates it.  Michigan is ranked #27 on KemPom and probably won’t move unless they can beat the Suckeyes…
Crashing the Dance has Michigan in the “Don’t Get Comfortable” At Large section, but the reasoning is flawed and isn’t consistent with what the committee appears to value at this point:  Big Games – Win or Lose.  I’ve never been a big fan of Crashing the Dance.  And the fact that he even has the Domers, Marquette, Miss St., Baylor, Texas and others as “having a chance” in the same section as Michigan and others is a farce.  When you get to Double Digit Losses, you better have some HUGE WINS in there somewhere.  So, whatever. 
And the Old Stand By:  RPI
Michigan currently ranked #37 in RPI.
Why Anyone is still using RPI (which is based only on W’s and L’s, SOS and other components) that doesn’t used adjusted stats is beyond me.  Whenever I see large, inconsistent gaps, it’s usually in the RPI.  And this is the main ranking criteria the Committee is still using.  They admittedly (FINALLY!) stated last season that they also “consider” and “review” the BPI ranking in their seeding evaluation, but not necessarily as part of “who gets in the dance”.  So, comparatively, Purdue, Sparty and the Suckeyes are 12, 14 and 17 in the RPI.  (And based on that you might ask:  How did Purdue get a 1-Seed as the 12th ranked RPI Team?)  I guess this reflects the “weak” B1G and the conference’s poor performance.  But I don’t think anyone believes that Purdue, Sparty or the Suckeyes aren’t Top 10 teams at this point.  So, yeah…  It’s a mess.
Call me when the Final 68 are named on Selection Sunday.
I wish I could do that…but the Basketball Junky in me can’t ignore this stuff. 
The Domers Get NCAA’d – Without Lube
Well, I have to admit, as much as I hate the Domers (JEEZ I HATE THESE GUYS!), as I’m sure everyone knows, I am today feeling a little bit (but not a lot) of empathy for them.  For those of you not aware – a recap:
In 2012-13, an Athletic Tutor who was dating a Domer Football player, wrote a couple of papers for 3 players on the Domer Football team.  The Domer’s administration discovered it, took it to the Honor Council, and the Student Athletes were given F’s for the courses and the administration also dismissed the students (expelled after the fact) from Notre Dame.
And then the Domers took everything to the NCAA in an effort to show transparency and FULL DISCLOSURE.
And what did the NCAA do?
They’ve kicked the Domers right in the collective nuts and vacated all the wins from the NC run in 2012 (12 victories) and the subsequent 2013 Season (9 victories). 
In other words, The Domers handed the NCAA the Bullet and The Gun, the NCAA loaded it, pointed at the Domers junk, and pulled the trigger.
Naturally, the Domers appealed. 
Yesterday, the NCAA held up their ruling to vacate the victories from 2012-13 due to the 3 student athletes who had papers written for them. 
3 student athletes...Papers written for them.  Like THAT’S NEVER HAPPENED ANYWHERE ELSE in Collegiate Athletics.
On a team of 85 players…That made it to the National Championship. 
This wasn’t everyone on the team getting strippers and hookers over a 2-year period paid for by a coach (Louisville).  This wasn’t Academic Fraud at the highest level (North Carolina) over a 20-year period where hundreds of Student Athletes on the football and basketball team took classes and received ABOVE passing grades and later earned degrees based on that fraudulent activity at north carolina. 
Nope – this was a couple of papers written for the players that they might have collaborated on (at the time, they said they did). 
And the Domers are getting hit right where it counts. 
For being honest. 
And transparent.
Here’s a link to Father Jenkins Letter to the Alumni of Notre Dame:
An Excerpt:
The NCAA has not chosen to ignore academic autonomy; it has instead perverted it by divorcing it from its logical and necessary connection to the underlying educational purpose. As noted above, Notre Dame’s exercise of academic autonomy in the form of the rigorous application of the University’s Honor Code was the source of the underlying violation on which the vacation of wins penalty is based. Although all parties acknowledged that Notre Dame did everything right in response to the academic misconduct, the University is now told that it must live with severe sanctions for its actions.
Notre Dame’s case stands in striking contrast with another recent high-profile academic misconduct case in which the NCAA Committee on Infractions chair explained that even though certain classes “more likely than not” were used to keep athletes eligible with fraudulent credits, the legitimacy of those classes was beyond the jurisdiction of the NCAA’s enforcement process precisely because that question must be left to the determination of the university in the exercise of its academic autonomy. The notion that a university’s exercise of academic autonomy can under NCAA rules lead to exoneration—or to a severe penalty—without regard to the way in which it is used defies logic and any notion of fundamental fairness. 
Read the entire letter.  I think Father Jenkins gets it just about right…And I relish the fact that he used “perverted” when referencing the NCAA’s logic in this case…Classic!!!
Hmmmm…I wonder how each and every University responds from this point forward when it comes to “disclosure” and dealing with the NCAA.  The Domers, unlike everyone in the SEC and north carolina, have tried to do things “The Right Way”.  You really shouldn’t get punished for that.  In fact, I’ll bet if you put it to a vote of the 129 FBS level Universities as to what the Domer punishment should be, they wouldn’t have voted (as a majority) to vacate those wins. 
Even this guy, if given the vote for the University of Michigan, wouldn’t have voted to take those wins away from the Domers.
I know, SHOCKING, right???!!!!
But the punishment, in all cases, needs to fit the crime.
This is one more nail in the NCAA’s coffin and this one, while seemingly small, just might be the one that breaks the ole’ camel’s back when it comes to all the D-1 Universities.  This is one that should’ve been reviewed in detail and a rational human being says, “Hey, The Domers punished the students.  This was NOT that big of an on-field advantage for the Domers.  We need to determine a punishment that doesn’t hurt the innocent players involved and administer that.” 
Please note I have no idea what that punishment should have been, but vacating all those victories wasn’t it.  Especially if you couldn’t do ANYTHING to punish north carolina. 
Maybe this is a good thing.  Maybe this finally gets the NCAA out of everyone’s hair and brings them down, once and for all. 
I doubt it, but one can hope. 
And at the end of the day, it makes this debate less entertaining: 


Judgement Day
The Faculty Board at MSU met yesterday and voted (to the tune of 96%!!!) no confidence on the MSU Board of Trustees. 
For the record, this carries no legal weight nor is it recognized by the administration or governance folks at MSU.  However, now that the vote is complete, they will request that the Entire Board resign their positions and step down.  I’m curious to see how this plays out, especially because some of the more outspoken idiots (Furgeson, Lyons, Breslin) are guys who really need to consider dismissing themselves.  I do believe if one goes, they all go, but there could be hold-outs.  And Furgeson is probably one. 
Gov Snyder could make himself a hero (after the Flint Crisis) if he waits for public sentiment to get stronger against the existing Board Members.  If several resign, he could can the rest a week later and he’s suddenly a great guy. 
We’ll see what happens.
And With February, Comes THIS!!!!
SI’s making of the Swim Suit Issue!



(Otherwise known as “Soft Porn for Dads”!!!)
Except now I do believe they are including guys in the shoot for the ladies as well.   Due to the fact that most of you reading this wouldn’t look good in the suits the guys are wearing….

No comments: